Consumers complain of bored and disinterested staff working in high street shops and utilities companies, according to the study among 2,000 consumers by the Institute of Customer Service.
Meanwhile, UK businesses may be missing an opportunity to maximize revenues, as one in four consumers are willing to pay more for their goods and services – on average 5 per cent more – for better service.
The research also reveals the extent to which ‘moments of truth’ – particularly good or bad customer service experiences – stick in the mind of consumers, driving them to spend and recommend, or the opposite.
Are you being served?
The Institute measured engagement levels of customer-facing staff by asking consumers to rate service personnel on a range of relevant factors, from the passion, enthusiasm and boredom levels, to the knowledgeability, helpfulness, and sense of pride they display.
Retail and utilities fared worst, with enthusiasm and passion for the job rated poorly on a scale of one to ten.
When asked how bored employees seemed, consumers rated staff in high street retail as 5.7 and utilities companies as 5.1.
At the opposite end of the scale, perhaps surprisingly consumers rate banks highly in terms of staff engagement, finding their customer services professionals to be the most friendly, helpful and enthusiastic.
Paying for service
One in four consumers would be prepared to pay more for an excellent service experience; on average 5 per cent more, but ranging in some instances to as much as 10 per cent.
Ultimately, consumers want the right balance between price and service, the study reveals. When asked to choose a point on a scale between those two factors, the largest proportion of consumers chose a middling 5 or 6.
Jo Causon, Chief Executive of the Institute of Customer Service, comments: “In this difficult economic environment, service is the critical differentiator for businesses. To make the most of this, companies need to train and motive staff to go the extra mile, while tailoring their service based on a firm understanding of what customers actually want.
“Even in these cost-conscious times, consumers still want the right balance between price and service. Those companies that can encourage staff to create a positive buying experience are more likely to retain customers and reap the financial rewards.”
Moments of truth
The research suggests that it is the exceptionally good and bad experiences that customers remember, with these ‘moments of truth’ ultimately driving consumer behaviour.
Almost a third of consumers have had a memorable service experience within the last 6 months, but worryingly only 57 per cent of these interactions were positive, whilst 43 per cent were negative.
Two thirds of the time those memorable experiences with banks or insurers were positive. Yet, when it comes to utilities companies, customers reported more bad experiences than good.
As well as the reputational effect of these experiences, ‘moments of truth’ also affect actual consumer behaviour and buying intentions.
Two thirds of those who had a good experience with a company have recommended the organisation to their peers.
But similarly, almost two thirds of customers that had a bad experience stopped doing business with the organisation, and a similar proportion spread negative word of mouth about the company.
Jo Causon, comments: “Ultimately, creating a good service experience has positive outcomes for organisations, while a bad experience makes costly, negative consumer behaviour far more likely. Companies are clearly still failing to realise the financial importance of good customer service, and communicate this to staff.
“Firms must do all they can to ensure their employees are engaged and committed to delivering the highest possible service quality. This will result in an engaged, energised workforce and a more profitable company.”